El Amigo and El Crítico are looking at the same flag: one calls it the reason to run it on a server, the other calls it the reason not to.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
The panel agrees on almost everything, which makes the one disagreement easy to find. El Amigo rates the cockpit highly because watching a run is the point. El Crítico rates reliability lower because the autonomous flag exists precisely so that nobody is watching, and one tool cannot claim credit for both. El Profesor sides with neither and points at the state files.
El Crítico wins on the flag and loses on the rest, because El Profesor's plain-text state means a bad run is legible afterwards. Adopt with conditions, the condition being that autonomous runs stay off until you have read a supervised one end to end.