El Profesor calls the design the most principled thing on this shelf; El Crítico notes the maintenance signal under it, and both statements are true at once.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Profesor's case is architectural: agent output lands as commits on a branch, so review is an ordinary git operation instead of a screenshot. El Crítico does not argue with the design. He argues with its cadence, an experimental badge and no tagged release since August 2025 on a component whose job is containment.
El Profesor wins on whether to use the idea and El Crítico on how far to trust the implementation, so neither is overruled outright. La Jefa's condition follows from his. Adopt with conditions: pin the version you install, and treat it as a convenience boundary rather than a security one.