La Jefa and El Crítico read the same permission engine and disagree about whether a policy without a boundary underneath it is a control or a preference.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
La Jefa scores this above her usual floor because a stated policy layer is the first thing in this class she can describe to an auditor. El Crítico scores reliability lower because policy decides what is permitted and nothing constrains what a permitted command can then reach. La Inversora dissents quietly: the audience it has is not the audience it claims.
El Crítico wins. A control that governs intent rather than reach is useful and is not the thing La Jefa's questionnaire is asking about, so she is overruled on sufficiency. Trial only, and the exit criterion is one project run end to end with the policy in enforcing mode.