El Hacker sits two points above El Crítico and El Profesor, and the gap is a default flag rather than a disagreement about the tool.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Hacker scores it highest for Apache-2.0, a versioned TOML config, MCP entries and ACP mounting. El Crítico read a different page: programmatic mode "falls back to auto-approve when --agent is not provided", and admin-managed config is "a distribution mechanism, not a security control". El Profesor scores lowest because 72.2% belongs to Devstral 2, not to the harness.
El Hacker's reading wins, since the configurability he scores is what fixes El Crítico's default. El Profesor is overruled on the score, not the point: the number matters when quoted, not when used. Adopt with conditions, the condition being --agent pinned in every scripted invocation before one reaches CI.