El Profesor and El Crítico examined the same routing record and disagreed about whether an audit trail counts as a control.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Profesor scores it well because every routing decision is written down, which makes the behaviour reconstructable after the fact. El Crítico scores reliability low because the tool declines to police anything it does: there is no permission layer, and isolation is described in documentation as something you arrange yourself.
El Crítico wins. A record of what happened is not a control over what happens, and El Profesor is overruled on the narrow point that logging substitutes for a gate. Adopt with conditions: run it inside one of the isolation patterns the documentation describes, before the first session, not after an incident.