El Profesor and El Crítico agree that the graph is the shipped artefact and disagree entirely about whether that is an achievement or a review problem.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Profesor credits the design because the thing you debug and the thing that runs in production are the same object, which removes a class of discrepancy. El Crítico answers that the same object is a document authored in a GUI, and that a team reviewing changes to it is reviewing something it cannot read line by line.
Both are describing a trade the vendor made deliberately. El Profesor wins where one or two people own the logic, El Crítico wins the moment a pull request has a second reader. Adopt with conditions, the condition being an agreed convention for how graph changes get reviewed.