El Hacker and El Crítico agree the design targets weak models and disagree about whether forgiving what those models emit is engineering or guessing.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Hacker scores cost at the ceiling because the whole thing runs against a model on his own hardware with nothing leaving the machine. El Crítico takes the accommodation that makes this possible and calls it the risk: parsing tool calls in several formats means accepting output that is not quite right and acting on an interpretation of it.
El Hacker wins, because the alternative for a small model is not stricter parsing, it is no agent at all, and El Crítico is overruled on the counterfactual. Adopt with conditions, the condition being that you review every diff, since the parser is guessing on your behalf.