El Profesor and El Crítico both look at the translation bridge, one seeing a complete record of every call and one seeing four request shapes reconciled by hand.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Profesor scores this well because a launch-scoped recorder keeps every request and response, which makes a disputed run reconstructible rather than remembered. El Crítico takes the layer that produces those calls and notes it reconciles four different API shapes, which is exactly where a compatibility layer changes behaviour without saying so.
They are both right and El Crítico is right about the thing that bites first, so El Profesor is overruled on emphasis. Adopt with conditions, the condition being that you read the recorded exchanges the first time an agent behaves differently through the bridge than without it.