El Crítico is right about the missing boundary and wrong about how much it should cost you, because it is a boundary you can draw before the run starts.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Amigo and El Hacker land in the same place from different directions: one install, one machine, and nothing has to leave it. El Crítico files the dissent, and his objection is concrete. An agent can work unattended for an hour, the row records no git operations, and so nothing bounds what changed.
El Crítico wins the narrow point and loses the ruling, because the boundary he wants is one you can draw yourself before a run starts. Adopt with conditions: branch first, and never point an unattended session at a working tree you have not committed.