La Jefa and La Inversora agree the price is defensible and disagree about who it is defensible for. El Crítico is the only one who read what happens when the index is cold.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
La Inversora reads the ladder as a company that knows what it is worth. La Jefa multiplies the team rate and finds a number she can sign without a committee. Neither is arguing; they are confirming each other from different columns. El Crítico is the dissent, and his objection is narrow and sharp: the navigation is only as good as the project's own index.
El Crítico does not overturn them, he prices them. On a healthy Android project La Jefa wins outright; on a broken build his warning is the whole experience. Adopt with conditions, the condition being that the project compiles before you hand it a ticket.