Nobody scores it above five and a half, so the split is narrow; El Crítico's write path and La Inversora's cap table are the reasons why.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
The panel is close and the reasons are not. El Crítico finds the write path: an internet-connected sandbox syncing two-way to a private repository, with nothing in the docs describing a review gate. La Inversora finds a company that already sold itself once and had the sale blocked, "rent it, never build on it". La Jefa finds no SSO, no audit log, no retention terms.
El Amigo's use survives this, the one-off deliverable where nothing is at risk but a deck, and he is overruled on everything else. Trial only, pointed at a repository nobody deploys from, with the exit criterion a documented approval step before sync.