El Amigo and El Crítico agree that the shared state is the whole idea and disagree about what it removes: manual handoff, or the human between two agents' mistakes.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Amigo values the thing the design is for: several agents referencing one set of conversations, files and outputs, with nobody copying context between them. El Crítico values what it removes: the moment a person reads one agent's output before it becomes another's input. Same mechanism, opposite emphasis.
El Crítico wins on risk and El Amigo wins on ambition, and neither is overruled, because a product this young has not yet demonstrated which reading holds. La Jefa's platform gap decides the corporate case against it. Trial only: the free local edition, one team, and approvals reviewed by a human every time until you have seen it be wrong.