El Hacker at 7.5 and La Jefa at 4.5 both read a plugin nobody sells; the split that matters is El Crítico against everyone, on whether the protocol survives.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Hacker likes a pure Lua implementation with no hidden dependencies. La Jefa has nothing to buy and therefore nothing to approve, which is a low score about a category rather than a product. El Crítico raises the only argument that changes a decision: the protocol was reverse-engineered from someone else's extensions and the vendor never promised to keep it.
He wins and both are overruled on longevity, because a compatibility layer against an undocumented interface bets on someone else's inertia. El Profesor is right that the design is elegant, and elegance does not renew the bet. Trial only, revisited when the vendor's own editor support covers your workflow.