La Jefa scores documented OIDC and per-user isolation; El Crítico scores a 2.0 rewrite sharing no code with the version those 81,000 stars belong to.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
A point and a half covers the panel, whose ends grade different codebases. La Jefa found OIDC single sign-on and per-user isolation written down, more than most free projects offer. El Crítico found that 2.0 shares no code with 1.x, so the stars and the closed issues describe a side branch.
El Crítico wins and La Jefa's approval is deferred, not denied: a security document written for a rewrite is a promise until someone runs it. El Hacker is overruled on longevity: a file for every piece is not a history. Trial only, reading the 2.0 issues alone, exiting when a platform owner has run it a quarter.