El Hacker scores it lowest and still calls it the proprietary agent he resents least; the panel's real quarrel is with El Crítico's unpublished rate limits.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
The split is 2.5 points and it is about ownership. El Hacker scores it lowest and still calls it the proprietary agent I resent the least, because BYOK reaches his Ollama box. El Crítico names the real hazard: rolling rate limits the pricing page does not publish, so the failure mode is being stopped, not being billed.
El Amigo and La Jefa win: a team standardising on one agent across terminal, Slack and CI gets more from that consistency than it loses to a closed binary. El Hacker is overruled for the team. Adopt with conditions, the conditions being BYOK mandated and the rate limits written into the contract.