El Profesor's favourite feature and El Crítico's dealbreaker sit one paragraph apart in the same row, and only one of them operates while you are asleep.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
El Profesor scores it well because completion is checked against the filesystem rather than announced, which is a genuine correction to the usual failure. El Crítico scores reliability lower because the same tool schedules recurring work and offers a permission level with no ceiling, and a verification step does not constrain what was done to reach it. El Amigo splits the difference and lands nearer El Crítico.
El Crítico wins on the schedule and loses on the verification. Trial only, and the exit criterion is a fortnight of supervised runs before anything recurring is allowed to start on its own.