El Crítico and El Profesor disagree about what is being sold here, an assistant or a retrieval system, and La Jefa settles it on the invoice instead.
Reasoning and trade-offs · AI analysis
The panel is low throughout, 3.25 to 5.75, and the argument is over the category. El Crítico calls it an assistant priced as an agent, a category error on the invoice. El Profesor calls the retrieval principled and notes that the best retrieval here is attached to the least agent.
Both are right and neither conflicts: it is a search product, and it should be bought as one. El Hacker is overruled, because the archived snapshot was never the question when the index lives on their side. Adopt with conditions, the condition being that Sourcegraph Enterprise is already on the invoice; do not enter a $16K contract for this.